News

For rural hospitals the struggle is real but unpredictable

Ridgecrest Regional Hospital. Photo by Leah O'Tarrow, Capitol Weekly.

The intensive care unit at Ridgecrest Regional Hospital (RRH) was empty.

Beds sat unused as hospital officials walked through the unit during a late-summer tour. There were no critically ill patients to monitor that morning, but the room could not simply be shut down. The hospital still needed the equipment, nurses and other staff necessary to care for someone if an emergency arrived.

“Sometimes this is full, and sometimes it’s empty,” RRH CEO Jim Suver said of the unit. “And you never know.”

That unpredictability is part of what makes operating a hospital in Ridgecrest so difficult. Nestled between desert mountains in eastern Kern County, the community sits hours from many of California’s larger cities. RRH therefore must maintain services residents may need urgently, even when not enough patients use them each day to cover the cost.

It is a problem that extends well beyond Ridgecrest. Across rural and remote California, hospitals are struggling to keep essential medical care available when there may not be enough patients to financially sustain every service.

Some hospitals are fighting to preserve services such as labor and delivery, while others are redesigning them entirely. California, meanwhile, is experimenting with new rural-health programs as lawmakers and hospital leaders debate whether the state should step in only when a hospital reaches financial distress or pay for some of the standby capacity remote communities depend on before a crisis arrives.

Across California, rural communities account for most of the state’s landmass but a small share of its population. Health Care Access Information (HCAI) counted 60 rural hospitals in 2024, 35 of them designated Critical Access Hospitals. Rural hospitals accounted for about 17% of hospitals statewide, but residents of rural areas made up just 7% of California’s population.

Ridgecrest Regional is not warning that it is about to shut its doors. Suver is careful about that distinction.

“We’re going to close” is the wrong message, he said. The more immediate risk is that the hospital eventually becomes unable to afford some of the services it offers.

The problems also predate the latest round of federal Medicaid changes. Ridgecrest has weathered the aftermath of the 2019 earthquakes, pandemic-era disruptions, workforce shortages, debt and years of financial losses. Its 2024 federal tax filing showed about $150 million in revenue and $155.6 million in expenses, a loss of about $5.6 million for the year.

But beneath those individual problems is an economic one that is harder to solve as many of the hospital’s expenses remain whether there are patients to pay for them or not.

“I approach this as pretty much a fixed-cost business,” Suver said. The mortgage on the hospital’s newer tower, he noted, is due “regardless if there’s 25 patients or two.”

Staffing can be adjusted somewhat, but only to a point.

Large hospitals can reduce staffing when patient volume drops because they have a much deeper labor pool. In Ridgecrest, repeatedly cutting a full-time nurse’s hours risks losing someone the hospital may struggle to replace. Suver said travelers can cost roughly three times what permanent employees do.

Glenn Melnick, a health economist and professor at the University of Southern California who has studied hospital finances and rural health care, said that distinction is one of the structural challenges facing small rural hospitals.

Large hospitals can reduce staffing when patient volume drops because they have a much deeper labor pool. In Ridgecrest, repeatedly cutting a full-time nurse’s hours risks losing someone the hospital may struggle to replace.

At a larger hospital, he said, if ICU occupancy drops, administrators may be able to tell several nurses not to come in that night.

“But that’s because they have access to a bigger workforce,” Melnick said. “In the rural area, maybe they only have one or two ICU nurses. And if you’re going to keep them, you’ve got to pay them.”

California’s own data reflects the unusual role these hospitals play. Rural hospitals averaged 44 general acute-care beds in 2024, compared with 225 at urban hospitals. Nearly all of the state’s rural hospitals provided emergency services.

“They’re much more always on the edge,” Melnick said.

A multimillion-dollar loss or a reimbursement delay that a large health system might absorb can have far greater consequences for an independent rural hospital operating close to break-even. Melnick said policymakers have to grapple with a system that still largely pays hospitals according to how much care they provide.

“We still have this old model where you’re basically paying on volume,” he said.

He argued that rural hospitals need financing that provides stability without removing incentives to operate efficiently.

RRH officials increasingly use the word “remote” rather than “rural” to describe their problem. The hospital is not necessarily among California’s smallest by volume. What distinguishes it is the distance separating the community from larger medical centers.

“We’re mostly remote,” said Rebecca Neipp, who works with the hospital on communications and advocacy. “We don’t have the lowest volume that other California institutions have. We are just very far away.”

That geography shapes nearly every decision about what care the hospital can provide.

RRH offers emergency care, surgery, intensive care, maternity services, pediatrics, primary care, imaging, laboratory services, skilled nursing, ambulance service and a network of outpatient clinics.

When patients need care beyond the hospital’s capabilities, they are transferred to larger facilities.

Kimberly Endicott, RRH’s quality and infection prevention manager, said the most difficult patients can be those in the middle. They are often too sick for RRH to provide all of the care they need but not in the kind of emergency that results in a quick flight to another hospital.

“There could be sheets of us calling 50 facilities,” Endicott said, searching for a hospital that has the appropriate specialist, an available bed, accepts the patient’s insurance and will take the case. “It’s the in-between,” she said.

That is one reason hospital officials say the question is not simply whether every service makes money. Suver said leadership weighs three things when deciding whether to maintain a service.

“Clinical quality of the program. Number two, the financial well-being of the program, and third, community need of the program,” he said.

Sometimes the answer is still no.

Ridgecrest once offered medical oncology. Community demand was clear, as cancer patients otherwise face long drives for treatment, but Suver said the hospital struggled to recruit oncologists and could not offer the same access to clinical trials as larger cancer programs.

But quality and finances pushed in the other direction. Larger programs could offer patients resources Ridgecrest could not. “It is terrible and necessary to stabilize our finances,” Suver said of eliminating oncology.

Labor and delivery has gone the other direction.

RRH temporarily suspended the service in March 2024, then reopened it later that year in Dec. It recruited Dr. Julene Evans as its first full-time OB/GYN since the reopening.

The hospital now handles roughly 30 to 40 births a month. Hospital officials say it would need closer to 60 to break even.

It is an issue across California, where just 27 of the state’s 60 rural hospitals provided maternity services in 2024. Rural residents accounted for about 7% of births statewide, but only about 3% occurred in rural hospitals, suggesting many rural women travel elsewhere to deliver.

Evans described practicing medicine in Ridgecrest as becoming part of the community, something harder to capture in the numbers.

The hospital now handles roughly 30 to 40 births a month. Hospital officials say it would need closer to 60 to break even.

“I’m here to embrace what it is,” Evans said of Ridgecrest. “I absolutely love it.”

Dr. Andrew Modic, who practices internal medicine and pediatrics, left Ridgecrest for a time before returning. He said relationships with local patients ultimately pulled him back.

“I have this strong relationship with patients,” Modic said. “Working in a small town … I take care of families and extended families, intergenerational.”

He compared hospital services to other basic infrastructure.

“In my opinion, it’s like having clean water or sewer services,” Modic said. “I don’t know how you could function without it.”

The hospital’s finances are further complicated by the way its pieces depend on one another. Suver said RRH subsidizes physician practices, as many hospitals do. On paper, reducing those subsidies could save money immediately. But doctors order the laboratory tests, imaging, procedures and hospital care that generate activity elsewhere in the system.

But without enough physicians, hospital volume eventually falls too.

“If I don’t do that, then I’m killing the hospital anyway,” he said, describing it as a longer “death by a thousand cuts.”

Ridgecrest has experimented with community paramedicine, home monitoring and other programs designed to keep patients healthier and prevent unnecessary emergency department visits or hospital stays.

Financially, every patient successfully kept out of the emergency room can also represent revenue the hospital does not collect, even though it must continue paying to keep the emergency department ready.

“In the rural area, maybe they only have one or two ICU nurses. And if you’re going to keep them, you’ve got to pay them.”

The pressures extend beyond government reimbursement.

Michelle Whalley, who works across RRH’s clinic and revenue operations, said the amount patients owe after insurance pays has climbed dramatically.

“The amount of money that we carry on after insurance, that’s patient responsibility, is staggering,” Whalley said.

She estimated it in the “tens of millions of dollars” for an organization with an annual operating budget of roughly $100 million.

“Are we not going to offer the care unless you pay? No, of course not,” Whalley said. “We’re always here to care for you first.”

RRH’s small size can also work against it when negotiating with national insurers.

“We are so small, we have zero leverage to negotiate with a great big Aetna or Blue Cross or United Healthcare to get prevailing rates,” Whalley said.

Melnick said that problem is not unique to Ridgecrest. He pointed to Madera Community Hospital’s temporary closure as one example of how allowing a small hospital to fail can ultimately push patients toward more expensive care elsewhere.

“The plan was pennywise and pound foolish,” Melnick said.

At Ridgecrest, the Naval Air Weapons Station China Lake (NAWS) is central to the local economy and depends heavily on specialized engineers, scientists and other civilian workers.  

Brad Harlow, former senior civilian leader at NAWS, said the base cannot accomplish its national security mission without attracting highly skilled workers to Ridgecrest.

“In order to be successful at that really important national security mission, we need the best of the best,” he said.

When he was first recruited to China Lake, he said, he was young and did not give much thought to whether there was a nearby hospital. “But we ended up having three kids. All were born at the hospital,” he said.

Those ordinary needs become part of whether a worker is willing to put down roots in an isolated community.

Ridgecrest police chief Mario Ysit put the relationship more bluntly.

“If the city falls apart, you’re not going to get a young engineer who wants to come and work out here and do the important things they do at the base,” he said. “If the base ever closes, the city doesn’t exist. We are symbiotic.”

That dependence on local institutions also helps explain why RRH officials say statewide policies can miss the realities of remote communities.

“When you live in Sacramento, and you’re writing policy for Ridgecrest, it may not immediately be obvious what our area needs versus what an urban or a metropolitan or a coastal community might need,” Neipp said.

This is the first of a two-part series on rural hospitals. 

Want to see more stories like this? Sign up for The Roundup, the free daily newsletter about California politics from the editors of Capitol Weekly. Stay up to date on the news you need to know.

Sign up below, then look for a confirmation email in your inbox.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Support for Capitol Weekly is Provided by: