Opinion

Proposition 40 failed, but California already suffered from it

Image by Mirza Kadic, iStock Images.

Capitol Weekly welcomes Opinions on California public policy or politics. Please read our guidelines for opinion pieces before submitting an Op-Ed. Submissions that do not adhere to our guidelines will not be considered for publication. 

OPINION — California voters rejected Proposition 40 on Election Day, turning down the one-time 5% tax on the net worth of the state’s roughly 400 billionaires. While opponents of the ballot measure are correct to call it a win for the state’s economy, the proposal itself has made California worse off.

The proposition set its residency date in January of 2026. This trick was so that billionaires could not avoid the tax by moving, since the residency date was 11 months before any billionaire knew if it passed or not. One of the designers of the bill, Gabriel Zucman, specifically said, “There is no incentive to move to another state.” 

However, in the roughly two-and-a-half months between the measure’s filing and the January residency date, seven billionaires publicly left, including Larry Page, Peter Thiel, Steven Spielberg and David Sacks. Together, they held over $500 billion in net worth, about a quarter of the state’s total billionaire wealth. 

Now, none of them, along with the billionaires that stayed, will pay the tax. But the billionaires that were pushed out by the threat of the wealth tax will also no longer pay income tax or California capital gains tax. That revenue is now gone anyways. A paper by Hoover Institute economists Jaros and Rauh estimates that California’s billionaires pay $3.3 billion to $5.8 billion a year in state income tax. Lose a quarter of that, and that is roughly a billion dollars year over year. 

Zucman previously argued that departures were irrational, since a one-time tax gives no one a reason to leave. However, there was nothing stopping California from trying to impose it again next election; it was simply just a promise to not. A meaningful enough chance of attempting this once, much less multiple times, was enough to chase away some of the state’s wealthiest residents. 

Regardless of the results itself, the fact that the proposition could get this close to passing anyways should be a warning call to Californians. The state has demonstrated that a wealth tax can be filed, qualified and put to voters. The labor union that sponsored the bill has promised to try again. Other variations of this bill can be tried again in the future. This will be a constant barrier for every founder or would-be-founder when deciding where to build their company. 

By trying to tax wealth based on residency retroactively, the state found itself in a lose-lose proposition. They won’t receive the wealth tax revenue, they scared away billionaires beforehand anyways, and now will have this constant uncertainty hanging in the balance. 

At the same time that Prop 40 failed, Proposition 3 passed, which would make the current tax rates for California residents earning more than $371,000 a year permanent. This suggests that voters in the state are not against high tax rates necessarily, which can lead to a further exodus of still largely mobile residents.

The correct response going forward should not be trying again with a lower threshold or a better residency date. Instead, it should recognize what the past year showed. Prop 40 targeted the most mobile taxpayers in the world, and the mere threat of taxing their wealth was enough to push out a quarter of the billionaires’ wealth. A state that is already the third most burdensome in the country, with a net domestic out-migration of more than three million people since 2010, cannot afford to keep taxing its way to prosperity.

Prop 40 lost this week, but California started losing because of it last year.

Justin T. Callais, PhD., serves as chief economist at the Archbridge Institute.

Want to see more stories like this? Sign up for The Roundup, the free daily newsletter about California politics from the editors of Capitol Weekly. Stay up to date on the news you need to know.

Sign up below, then look for a confirmation email in your inbox.


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Support for Capitol Weekly is Provided by: