Micheli Files
Using and drafting definitions in California legislation
Definitions can play an important role in legislation. Defining words or phrases is done to provide the reader of the legislative text with clear guidance regarding how those words or phrases are to be understood. Where there are multiple definitions, they are most often found near the beginning of legislative text.
This is because it makes them easier to find for the reader and instructs the reader how these words or phrases should be used when reading the remainder of the statutory provisions. In some jurisdictions, such as the United Kingdom, definitions are actually placed at the end of the legislation pursuant to their parliamentary practice.
According to the Athabasca University’s Graduate Diploma in Legislative Drafting program, “essentially, definitions can perform two different functions: labelling and stipulating.” A labelling definition’s purpose is to allow the term to be used instead of a longer sentence that sets forth the definition repeatedly throughout the legislative text. A stipulating definition’s purpose is to provide a specific meaning for the defined term or phrase as it is to be used in the legislation.
For purposes of drafting definitions in legislation, bill drafters are to obviously follow the drafting guidelines of their jurisdiction, but much of this area is common among the states. Drafters generally develop definitions in the planning stage of preparing legislation to draft when they anticipate certain words or phrases will need to be defined, as well as when they are actually drafting because they have determined that a definition would help explain a word or phrase used in the legislative text.
In some legislation, there is an entire definitions section, which often begins with an introductory phrase such as: “For purposes of this chapter (or act, or section), the following definitions apply:” Another example from California law is: “For purposes of this article, the following terms have the following meanings:”
Thereafter, the word or phrase is defined, with that word or phrase in quotation marks according to California’s drafting style. In some jurisdictions, boldface or italics are instead used for the word or phrase that is being defined. The word or first word of a phrase is not usually started with a capital letter and does not include a definite (“the”) or indefinite (“a” or “an”) article.
What are the types of definitions commonly found in legislation? A comprehensive definition includes a complete statement of what the defined term means. It is concise and includes the entire definition. An example in California law would be: “(b) “Contractor” means an individual, business, or other entity doing business with an agency.”
A restricting definition limits the use of a term to the specific context of the particular legislation. An example in California law would be: “(6) “Patient information” shall mean identifiable private information, protected health information, individually identifiable health information, or medical information.”
An enlarging definition is intended to extend the usual definition of a word. An example in California law would be: “(k) “Commercial cannabis activity” includes the cultivation, possession, manufacture, distribution, processing, storing, laboratory testing, packaging, labeling, transportation, delivery, or sale of cannabis and cannabis products as provided for in this division.”
Another example from California law is: “(p) “Delivery” means the commercial transfer of cannabis or cannabis products to a customer. “Delivery” also includes the use by a retailer of any technology platform.” Another example from California law would be: “(c) “Protective hairstyles” includes, but is not limited to, such hairstyles as braids, locks, and twists.”
An excluding definition is used to remove something from the usual meaning of a word or phrase. An example in California law would be: ““Employer” does not include a religious association or corporation not organized for private profit.” Another example from California law would be: “(f) “Essential functions” means the fundamental job duties of the employment position the individual with a disability holds or desires. “Essential functions” does not include the marginal functions of the position.”
A referential definition utilizes a defined term in another area of statutory law by specifically referring to that particular definition and where it is found in the law. An example in California law would be: “(a) “Agency” has the same meaning as in subdivision (b) of Section 1798.3 of the Civil Code.”
As a general rule of legislative drafting, for a comprehensive definition, the drafter should use the word “means.” The word “includes” is not usually viewed as creating a comprehensive definition. Drafters should never use the phrase “means and includes”. In addition, a definition is usually not required to merely repeat a dictionary definition. Judges expect a definition to be needed when the common dictionary term is not being used.
Definitions of words and phrases play an important part in statutes, particularly where these words or phrases are not used in their common, ordinary manner. When a drafter defines a term in a legislative text, then the defined word or phrase must be used in that same manner throughout the text of the statute.
Definitions found in statutes need to be carefully written and ensure clarity in laws. Definitions are generally provided when a word has several different usages, as well as to avoid repetition of a phrase. There are a number of important guidelines when drafting definitions in statutes.
For example, use the word “means” to set forth a full meaning of a word. Use the phrase “includes, but not limited to,” to set forth a meaning in addition to a word’s usual use. According to some legal commentators, a definition that is restrictive is followed by the word “means.” A definition that is extensive is followed by the word “includes.”
It is important to not use the defined word in the definition itself, as well as to not include substantive provisions in a definition. For example, do not include a requirement that an agreement must be in writing by defining the word “agreement” to mean “a written agreement.” A definition should not contain substantive law in addition to the definition since the substantive law would be “hidden” in a place the reader would not expect to find it.
If a word is already defined in another statute, the drafter may cite that statute by cross-reference instead of repeating the definition. This has the advantage of promoting statutory uniformity. Defining a term by reference is accomplished in the same way as any other reference, by providing the Code citation for the definition being referenced.
In terms of placement, definitions should ordinarily be set forth at the beginning of the bill, and they should be arranged in alphabetical order. Thereafter, use the defined word in the statute, rather than the definition.
In drafting definitions, legislative lawyers ask a number of questions, including: Should the definitions be contained individual code sections? Or, should the definitions be contained in subdivisions of a single code section? Is there an existing definition in another statute to utilize? Should the definition cross-reference another code section containing a definition? Does the definition need to be modified for this particular statutory scheme?
The following are some examples of how these questions are addressed in current legislation before the California Legislature:
(b) For purposes of this section, the following terms have the following meanings:
(1) “Ammunition” means the term as defined in subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 16150 of the Penal Code.
(2) “Firearm” means the term as defined in subdivisions (a) and (b) of Section 16520 of the Penal Code.
In the above example, the definitions are contained in a single code section with each individual subdivision containing each defined term. The definitions cross-reference an existing definition for those terms. And, the section uses the introductory phrase: “the following terms have the following meanings.”
(c) For purposes of this section:
(1) “Development fee” has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (b) of Section 66000.
(2) “Large jurisdiction” has the same meaning as defined in subdivision (d) of Section 53559.1 of the Health and Safety Code.
In the above example, the definitions are also contained in a single code section with each individual subdivision containing a defined term. The language used differs slightly from the first example because the phrase “has the same meaning as defined in” is used in this example. And, the section uses a different introductory phrase: “For purposes of this section:”
Section 6150. “Natural and working lands-based carbon sequestration” means sustainable resource management practices, changes in land use, preservation of natural resources, fuel reduction or prescribed fire activities, and other practices that result in the long-term removal, capture, or sequestration of carbon dioxide from the atmosphere to slow or reverse atmospheric carbon dioxide pollution and to mitigate or reverse global warming.
Section 6151. “Natural lands” has the same meaning as in paragraph (2) of subdivision (d) of Section 9001.5 of the Public Resources Code.
Section 6152. “Whole orchard recycling” means the onsite grinding or chipping of whole trees during orchard removal, and incorporation of the ground or chipped biomass into the topsoil prior to replanting.
In the above example, the definitions are contained in separate code sections, rather than in subdivisions under the same code section. The definitions include both full definitions, as well as one cross-referencing an existing code section using the same term.
As the above examples indicate, there is not a single method of defining terms in California statutes. Bill drafters should be familiar with different approaches that can be used.
Want to see more stories like this? Sign up for The Roundup, the free daily newsletter about California politics from the editors of Capitol Weekly. Stay up to date on the news you need to know.
Sign up below, then look for a confirmation email in your inbox.
Leave a Reply