Carrie Nevans should be confirmed as workers’ comp director

The 2008 session of the California Legislature does not lend itself to significant legislation on workers’ compensation issues. The Legislature will be preoccupied with trying to deal with a $14 billion budget deficit in an election year. However, it can be logically expected that leadership will once again attempt to get the governor to budge on permanent disability benefits. Beyond that, though, reforming the reform expectations should be diminished. But there will be workers’ comp issues of import to both employers and labor.

There is one particular issue that, in the spirit of “post-partisanship,” should be addressed and addressed promptly. This is the confirmation of Carrie Nevans as administrative director of the Division of Workers’ Compensation. Workers’ Comp Executive enthusiastically endorses Nevans’ confirmation.

Her tenure began with a system high on expectations and low on facts. Through this period, she has shown an unwavering fairness to employers and workers, to business and labor while maintaining fidelity to the spirit and the letter of AB227, SB228, and SB899. Nevans has also brought increased transparency — and therefore credibility — both to the process and to the department.

Increased transparency always has credibility as its main benefit. The myriad of special interests have been able to see the system operate, and for the most part, to accept the outcomes.

As has been the case since the reforms of 1989, the Legislature has consigned much of the details of the system to the division and to the Workers’ Comp Appeals Board.

While the WCAB has lagged in exercising its authority over judges to curb the litigation abuses in the system, the division, under Nevans’ leadership, has moved forward to implement and enforce the law. This is a refreshing approach given that some judges appear still to be in a state of reform denial.

Recognizing that workers’ compensation is a system in which no stakeholder will be entirely pleased with the outcomes, the administrative director has called out payers when they irrationally deny benefits with the same zeal that she decries the efforts of applicant attorneys to judicially unwind core elements of SB899. The division’s spirited and well-reasoned defense of the permanent disability rating schedule is a template for the appellate courts and exposes the unfounded challenges that would return PD to the litigation machine that existed prior to SB899.

The complexities of the system remain up to the Legislature to resolve. The delays caused by providers who continue to resist the changes made by the Legislature in SB228 and SB899, the extreme measures by which judges undermine these reforms, and the frustrations surrounding the potentially insurmountable barriers to effective return-to-work programs are beyond the ability of the AD to resolve.

Nevans’ confirmation should not, indeed must not, become a proxy battle for all who are disenchanted with the current state of the law. What she has been given the authority to do she has done promptly and intelligently. We are hopeful that how well she has carried out her responsibilities will be the sole criterion by which the Senate Rules Committee bases its decision.

The impending budget fiasco places many, many things on the table in order to get the requisite votes to send up a spending plan to the governor. If 2007 was a terrible year by budget standards, just wait for this year. To the extent the president pro tem wants leverage to address the PD benefit issue, there are ample opportunities. Denying confirmation and forcing a change in leadership at the Division of Workers’ Compensation, however, should not be part of that horse trading. This is one of those rare opportunities for policymakers to do the right thing with no strings attached. Rarer still is when this is within in realm of workers’ compensation.

There is nothing to gain and much to lose if Nevans is not confirmed or is allowed to languish as a “364-day AD.” The clock is ticking.

Want to see more stories like this? Sign up for The Roundup, the free daily newsletter about California politics from the editors of Capitol Weekly. Stay up to date on the news you need to know.

Sign up below, then look for a confirmation email in your inbox.


Support for Capitol Weekly is Provided by: